Talk:Whitefish Bay

Body of water article? Region article?

A nice start on this article but there is a little problem: we don't do articles on bodies of water unless they represent a clearly defined land region, usually as a region article which is part of a region breakdown. This article, however is so far set up kind of like a city page, yet one of the listings here actually belongs at Paradise (Michigan), since we don't duplicate listings. I think a decision needs to be made here: either

• this article should be treated as a conglomerate city article including Paradise and Brimley etc.,in which case Paradise needs to be merged and redirected here, or
• general info on the bay itself needs to be covered in Upper Peninsula and specific listings need to be covered in the specific articles like Paradise (Michigan) and Brimley

We can't really do both. So which should it be? Texugo (talk) 02:00, 9 August 2014 (UTC)

There's basically nothing listed for Paradise MI on that page; you have turned that article into a w:WP:HATRACK to cover primarily Whitefish Point. I strongly disagree and have moved this to Paradise and Whitefish Bay to cover the entire large rural area instead of just one village with no local listings. K7L (talk) 03:04, 4 November 2016 (UTC)